The carbon button microphone was developed by Emile Berliner and Thomas Edison in the late 19th century

Vitaphone system used the Western Electric 1B carbon microphone (hanging above) in 1925

The earliest attempts to synchronize sound with motion pictures date back to the late 19th century. In 1895, Thomas Edison and his team of engineers developed the Kinetophone, a pioneering device that combined Edison’s phonograph with his Kinetoscope motion picture viewer. The Kinetophone presented sound on a wax cylinder phonograph, which was mechanically synchronized to the film. Despite its ingenuity, the Kinetophone faced multiple limitations, such as poor sound quality and synchronization issues, which hindered its widespread adoption.

In the following decades, several inventors and engineers continued to experiment with various methods of synchronizing sound and image. In 1902, Léon Gaumont introduced the Chronophone, which employed compressed air amplification to project sound, while in 1919, American inventor Lee De Forest developed the Phonofilm, an optical sound-on-film process that recorded sound directly onto the filmstrip. However, these early innovations still failed to gain traction in the film industry, largely due to their technical shortcomings and lack of commercial appeal.

The breakthrough that paved the way for the widespread adoption of synchronized sound in motion pictures came in 1926, with the introduction of the Vitaphone system. Developed by Western Electric and the Warner Bros. studio, Vitaphone utilized a sound-on-disc process, in which a phonograph record was synchronized with the film projector. The Vitaphone system made its debut with the premiere of “Don Juan” (1926), a film starring John Barrymore that featured a synchronized orchestral score and sound effects, though not spoken dialogue.

The true arrival of sound in motion pictures, however, is often attributed to the release of “The Jazz Singer” (1927), also produced by Warner Bros. and utilizing the Vitaphone system. The film, starring Al Jolson, combined synchronized musical numbers with intermittent spoken dialogue, marking the first instance of a commercially successful film with audible speech. The Jazz Singer’s unprecedented success signaled the beginning of the sound era in cinema, leading to a rapid and transformative shift in the industry.

As sound technology continued to advance, the Vitaphone sound-on-disc system was soon eclipsed by optical sound-on-film processes, such as Movietone and Photophone, which offered improved synchronization and sound quality.

Optical sound-on-film processes are methods of recording and reproducing synchronized sound in motion pictures by encoding audio information directly onto the filmstrip. Unlike the sound-on-disc systems, such as Vitaphone, which relied on separate phonograph records for audio playback, optical sound-on-film processes integrated sound and image on the same medium, offering improved synchronization and sound quality.

Two prominent optical sound-on-film processes emerged in the late 1920s: Movietone and Photophone.

Movietone, developed by Theodore Case and Earl Sponable, was introduced by the Fox-Case Corporation in 1926. The Movietone process used a variable-density method, where the sound was encoded as varying shades of gray on the filmstrip, representing the audio waveform. This technology was first used in a newsreel, “Fox Movietone News,” which captured Charles Lindbergh’s historic transatlantic flight in 1927. Fox Film Corporation later adopted the Movietone system for their feature films, starting with “Sunrise” (1927), directed by F. W. Murnau.

Photophone, on the other hand, was developed by Western Electric and RCA (Radio Corporation of America) in the late 1920s. Photophone utilized a variable-area method, in which the audio waveform was represented by varying widths of transparent and opaque lines on the filmstrip. The first feature film to use the Photophone process was “The Lion’s Roar,” a short film released by MGM (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer) in 1928. RKO Radio Pictures, another major studio, also adopted Photophone for their sound productions.

Both Movietone and Photophone systems relied on a light-sensitive device, such as a photocell, to convert the optical sound information back into electrical audio signals during projection. This was achieved by shining a light through the filmstrip’s audio track, causing variations in the light intensity, which the photocell then transformed into audio signals.

By the early 1930s, the talkies had become the standard in motion picture production, effectively ending the silent film era.

The early years of sound cinema saw the development and adoption of various microphone technologies, which were crucial for capturing dialogue, music, and sound effects. As studios and engineers adapted to the new era of talkies, several microphone models emerged as vital tools for film production. Some of the most notable early movie microphones are:

  1. Carbon Button Microphone: One of the first microphones used in the film industry, the carbon button microphone was initially developed by Emile Berliner and Thomas Edison in the late 19th century. The carbon microphone operates on the principle of varying electrical resistance as carbon granules are compressed and decompressed by sound waves. Though it offered relatively low fidelity and a limited frequency response, the carbon button microphone was widely used in the early days of sound film production, primarily due to its affordability and simplicity.
  2. Western Electric Condenser Microphone: Western Electric, a major player in the development of film sound technologies, introduced their condenser microphones in the late 1920s. Condenser microphones use a charged diaphragm and a fixed backplate to create a capacitor that changes its capacitance with sound pressure variations. The Western Electric condenser microphones provided a higher fidelity and wider frequency response compared to carbon microphones. They were used in several early sound film productions, including the pioneering talkie “The Jazz Singer” (1927).
  3. RCA 44A and 44B Ribbon Microphones: Ribbon microphones, introduced in the early 1930s, use a thin metal ribbon suspended in a magnetic field to convert sound pressure into electrical signals. RCA’s 44A and 44B were among the first ribbon microphones used in the film industry. These microphones offered a natural, smooth sound quality and excellent directionality, making them ideal for capturing dialogue and music on film sets. The RCA 44 series microphones became a standard in the industry and were used extensively throughout the 1930s and beyond.
  4. Western Electric 618A Dynamic Microphone: Western Electric introduced the 618A dynamic microphone in 1931, which quickly gained popularity in the film industry. Dynamic microphones use a diaphragm connected to a coil within a magnetic field, and the coil’s motion generates an electrical signal. The 618A model boasted a robust and durable design and provided a balanced, clear sound. It became a go-to choice for both indoor and outdoor film recordings during the early years of talkies.

The evolution of movie sound technology from the 1930s through the 1950s witnessed significant advancements in audio recording, reproduction, and playback systems. This period was marked by the maturation of sound-on-film processes, the introduction of multi-channel sound, and innovations in speaker design and playback systems.

Key developments in movie sound technology from the 1930s through the 1950s include:

Improved Microphones: Throughout the 1930s, microphone technology continued to advance, with newer models offering better sound quality and frequency response. Ribbon microphones, such as the RCA 44 series and the Western Electric/Altec 639A and 639B, became popular due to their smooth and natural sound quality, while dynamic microphones, like the Western Electric 618A, gained traction for their durability and balanced audio reproduction.

Noise Reduction: One of the primary challenges in early sound film production was minimizing background noise during recording. In the 1930s, filmmakers started using “blimps,” large soundproof housings that enclosed cameras to reduce mechanical noise. Sound stages were also redesigned with improved soundproofing and acoustics to minimize noise and reverberation.

Introduction of Optical Soundtracks: During the 1930s, the use of optical soundtracks on film became standardized. Both variable-density (Movietone) and variable-area (Photophone) optical soundtracks were employed, enabling consistent and reliable audio reproduction. By the end of the decade, variable-area optical soundtracks had become the dominant method due to their superior sound quality and ease of reproduction.

Multi-Channel Sound: The introduction of multi-channel sound, also known as stereophonic or surround sound, marked a significant advancement in movie sound technology. In 1940, Walt Disney’s “Fantasia” became the first commercial film to use a multi-channel sound system called Fantasound. This innovative system utilized separate audio channels for music, dialogue, and sound effects, and employed multiple speakers positioned around the theater to create an immersive audio experience.

Magnetic Sound Recording: In the late 1940s, the development of magnetic sound recording offered an alternative to optical soundtracks. Magnetic soundtracks provided higher fidelity, a broader frequency response, and lower noise levels. Magnetic sound technology also allowed for multi-track recording and mixing, which facilitated the adoption of multi-channel sound systems in film production.

CinemaScope and Cinerama: In the early 1950s, widescreen film formats, such as CinemaScope and Cinerama, emerged as a response to the growing popularity of television. These formats utilized multi-channel sound systems to complement their immersive visual experiences. CinemaScope, introduced by 20th Century Fox in 1953 with “The Robe,” employed a four-track magnetic soundtrack, while Cinerama, showcased in “This is Cinerama” (1952), used a seven-channel magnetic sound system.

Improvements in Speaker Design and Playback Systems: The 1950s saw advancements in speaker design and playback systems, which allowed for more powerful and accurate audio reproduction in theaters. The development of horn-loaded speakers and the introduction of Altec Lansing’s “Voice of the Theatre” speaker system contributed to enhancing the movie-going experience with clearer and more immersive sound.


Media Production by Andrew Gupta  |  andrewgupta.com  |  andrewgupta.media  |  gupta.studio  |  Copyright 2020 Andrew Gupta